Back

The Comparison of Learning Effectiveness Between Picture, Video, Subtitle and Narration Multimedia Teaching Materials for Bird Identification:A Case Study of University Students in Taiwan

Chen Shih-Yu
National Taiwan Normal University Graduate Institute of Sustainability Management and Environmental Education Student
E-mail:joshua861119@gmail.com

Chang Tzu-Chau
National Taiwan Normal University Graduate Institute of Sustainability Management and Environmental Education Professor Emeritus
E-mail:tcchang@ntnu.edu.tw

Shih-Jang Hsu
National Dong Hwa University Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Studies Professor
E-mail:sjhsu@gms.ndhu.edu.tw

Download PDF

Abstract

This study examines how different multimedia elements (pictures, videos, subtitles, and narration) affect college students’ bird identification skills, a key competency in citizen science. Based on the Cognitive Theory of Multimedia Learning, a quasi-experimental design was used to divide participants into three groups: picture with subtitle, video with subtitle, and video with narration. Pre- and post-test results indicated that while all three instructional formats significantly improved learning outcomes, there were no significant differences among the groups.

 Keywords:Multimedia learning, bird identification, citizen science, picture, subtitle, video, narration